Source : Star Wars : Tantive 'Orange Errors' Guide




Explanation : In the 1977 movie 'Star Wars', early on in the film is an item/error/object which appears for multiple frames. See 'Guide' for visual identification. These items/errors/objects have appeared, disappeared, reappeared and disappeared as the movie was released in various home versions.
Purpose : To document the variations. Then to hypothesize : What they are? (rips, burns, transfer errors, ?) : Why they occurred? : What caused them? : Figure out why certain versions do/don't have them, and see how that can help determine which home video versions originated from a print of the movie which is closest to the original 'Star Wars' negative.
Online discussion of the Star Wars Tantive 'Orange Item' frames:
Note : Click 'Source' to show screen captures. All screen captures shown at reduced size. Scroll over for full size. (HTML5 Browsers)
Key (Background color)OrangeErrorA has remnants of the error. (See floor line left of 3po's knee) OrangeErrorB's floor line is not straight.
OrangeErrorA has remnants of the error. (See floor line left of 3po's knee) OrangeErrorB's floor line is not straight.
OrangeErrorA has remnants of the error. (See floor line left of 3po's knee) OrangeErrorB's floor line is not straight.
OrangeErrorA has remnants of the error. (See floor line left of 3po's knee) OrangeErrorB's floor line is not straight.
OrangeErrorA has remnants of the error. (See floor line left of 3po's knee) OrangeErrorB's floor line is not straight.
OrangeErrorA has remnants of the error. (See floor line left of 3po's knee) OrangeErrorB's floor line is not straight.
OrangeErrorA has remnants of the error. (See floor line left of 3po's knee) OrangeErrorB's floor line is not straight.
OrangeErrorA has remnants of the error. (See floor line left of 3po's knee) OrangeErrorB's floor line is not straight.
OrangeErrorA has remnants of the error. (See floor line left of 3po's knee) OrangeErrorB's floor line is not straight.
A 35mm print frame size is approximately 1 3/8" wide. (35mm) Orange Items A.1 and B.2 almost make a circle of about half and inch. This is close to the width of a finger, so speculation might suggest during one of the emulsion processes, someone accidentally touched and modified this negative or IP or print. Orange Items B.3 and C.4 have a similar frame location, and happen consecutively, so possibly these were created by a mechanical process. Orange Item D.5, we're not sure about. It first came to our attention by the provider of the 35mm scans. We hadn't seen this Item in other version of the film.
Early Home Video versions used the same negative/IP/print of the film as it was shown in theaters. But then in the early 80s, this changed and a negative/IP/print without the Orange Items was used for multiple home video versions. Then the Orange Items returned for the final home video release pre-Special Edition. Once the 1997 Special Edition occurred, we are speculating that a new negative or IP was used for this sequence. The shot has been significantly reframed and does not contain the Orange Items.
See links at the top of page for the currently happening discussions.
Quote from page 53 of The Sounds of Star Wars by J.W. Rinzler
As Ben Burtt calls out that he was working on a 'work print' this possible explanation of the origins of the Tantive 'Orange Items' is most likely false.